In writing, how you describe characters is crucial to the
meaning of the story. You cannot
have a plot without specific character traits, however the real craft is how
you write these traits. Recently, I read the book “The Cuckoo’s Calling,”
by Robert Galbraith and the way Galbraith writes the characters is extremely
stereotypical and unfair.
Sometimes authors use artistic license as an excuse to portray
characters in a stereotypical manner.
In
the beginning of the book, we learn the characters were all divided into social
classes. For example, the protagonist
is labeled working class by the other characters and essentially the
author. Every one treats him
differently and Galbraith gives him this military background and an upsetting
parental story. All of that
defines his character as lesser and that is a social injustice. Following that, the author puts certain
characters into the upper class and makes all of their actions very similar and
generic. By doing so the author is
classifying the wealthier characters as more or less the same.
Along
the same lines, Galbraith introduces character Raquel. Raquel is a young black woman that was
friends with the victim. She is described in an offensive manner. Regardless of her skin color or role in
the story the way she is presented is quite rude and mean way. For example, her
clothes are described as tacky and inappropriate. Second, the way in which she speaks is both unrealistic and
uneducated. Lastly, whenever they
describe her, they use her race as a defining physical and mental trait. How
Raquel was written showed me that the author not only embraced stereotypes, but
also used them to her advantage,
Overall,
there are many social issues in books having to do with the stories, but there
can be just as many social offenses that were devised by the authors themselves. Stereotypes are all about judgment; so
one question we must consider is if it is ok to be rude for effect.
Okay, okay...Hold up...Are you meaning to tell me that authors cannot make decisions for their characters? NEWSFLASH, Soph, but these characters don't actually exist, and therefore the author was required to make choices, including those of class and race. Now, I understand that you may find some of these choices offensive, but this book was written by J.K. Rowling, yes? When most people hear her name, they aren't usually struck with thoughts of stereotypical behavior. No offense, love-but I disagree. BOOM!
ReplyDeleteInteresting perspective Henry, we'll have to chat more about that in class
ReplyDelete